The Good Immigrant

Key Takeaways

1. The Burden of "Good" Immigrant Status

...the biggest burden facing people of colour in this country is that society deems us bad immigrants – job-stealers, benefit-scroungers, girlfriend-thieves, refugees – until we cross over in their consciousness...to become good immigrants.

Conditional acceptance. People of color often feel pressured to prove their worth and justify their presence in society, constantly striving to meet the expectations of a "good immigrant" to be accepted. This burden is exhausting and unfair, as it implies that their inherent value is contingent on their perceived contributions.

The "good immigrant" myth:

• Perpetuates the idea that immigrants are inherently "bad" until they prove otherwise.
• Forces people of color to constantly perform and conform to societal expectations.
• Ignores the systemic barriers and prejudices that immigrants face.
• Creates a hierarchy of worth based on perceived contributions to society.

This constant need to justify their existence is a heavy burden that people of color carry, and it highlights the systemic racism that permeates society. It's a reminder that acceptance should not be conditional, and that everyone deserves to be treated with dignity and respect, regardless of their background.

2. Navigating Racial Identity: A Complex Journey

For mixed-race children it’s a little more confusing. We don’t always come out looking like our parents, and often we’ll be racialised differently to them.

Fluidity of identity. Racial identity is not always straightforward, especially for mixed-race individuals who may be racialized differently than their parents and struggle to find a sense of belonging. This journey of self-discovery is often marked by confusion, self-doubt, and the need to reconcile different aspects of their heritage.

The "Oreo" label:

• Highlights the pressure to conform to a singular racial identity.
• Demonstrates the limitations of binary racial categories.
• Underscores the challenges of navigating multiple cultural influences.

Beyond mixed-race:

• Even those who identify with a single race may experience a complex relationship with their identity.
• The way one is perceived by others can differ from how one sees themselves.
• The journey of self-discovery is ongoing and multifaceted.

The process of understanding one's racial identity is a personal and often challenging one, and it's important to recognize the diversity of experiences within and across racial groups.

3. Names, Language, and the Weight of Heritage

Words, names, and their noises are careless in England. They are not put to use in the way that obstructed communities have learned to pronounce every violence put upon us as though it is sacred.

Names as identity markers. Names carry cultural significance and can be a source of pride and connection to one's heritage. However, they can also be a source of discrimination and mispronunciation, highlighting the challenges of navigating a dominant culture that often disregards or misinterprets non-Western names.

The power of language:

• Language is a carrier of culture and history.
• The way we speak can be a source of both connection and alienation.
• The dominant culture often imposes its own linguistic norms, marginalizing other languages and accents.

The burden of translation:

• Immigrants and their children often have to navigate multiple languages and cultural codes.
• They may feel pressure to conform to the dominant language and culture, losing touch with their heritage.
• The act of translation can be a form of violence, erasing the nuances and complexities of other languages.

The way we use names and language is not neutral, and it's important to be mindful of the power they hold and the impact they can have on individuals and communities.

4. The Performance of Blackness and the Power of Hair

Nobody knows the transformative power of a new hairstyle like a black woman.

Black hair as a political statement. Black hair is not just a matter of personal style; it is often a political statement, a symbol of identity, and a site of cultural resistance. The way black women choose to wear their hair can be a way of reclaiming their heritage and challenging dominant beauty standards.

The struggle for acceptance:

• Black women often face pressure to conform to Eurocentric beauty standards.
• Natural hairstyles are often deemed unprofessional or distracting.
• The pressure to straighten or alter their hair can be a source of pain and frustration.

The transformative power of hair:

• A new hairstyle can be a powerful act of self-expression and self-discovery.
• It can be a way of reclaiming one's identity and feeling beautiful.
• It can be a way of connecting with one's heritage and community.

The journey of learning to love and care for natural hair is a journey of self-acceptance and empowerment, and it's a reminder that beauty comes in many forms.

5. Challenging Stereotypes: Beyond the Model Minority

Integrate well. Move upwards in society. Be praised – until people worry that you’re doing too well, and then they remember that you’re foreign.

The myth of the model minority. The stereotype of East Asians as a "model minority" is a harmful and limiting construct that ignores the diversity of experiences within the community and perpetuates harmful stereotypes about other racial groups. It also masks the systemic barriers and prejudices that East Asians face.

The pressure to conform:

• East Asians are often expected to be quiet, hardworking, and successful.
• This pressure can lead to feelings of isolation and a lack of belonging.
• It can also mask the struggles and challenges that many East Asians face.

Beyond the stereotype:

• East Asians are not a monolithic group, and their experiences are diverse.
• They have a wide range of talents, interests, and aspirations.
• They should not be defined by stereotypes or limited by expectations.

It's important to challenge the myth of the model minority and recognize the full humanity of East Asians, allowing them to be seen as individuals with their own unique stories and experiences.

6. The Struggle for Representation: Visibility and Erasure

[The oriental woman] never spoke of herself … never represented her emotions, presence or history.

The power of representation. The lack of representation of people of color in media and popular culture can lead to feelings of invisibility and erasure. When people don't see themselves reflected in the stories that are being told, they may feel like they don't belong or that their experiences don't matter.

The impact of stereotypes:

• When people of color are represented, they are often portrayed in stereotypical or limiting ways.
• These stereotypes can reinforce harmful biases and prejudices.
• They can also prevent people of color from seeing themselves as complex and multifaceted individuals.

The need for authentic voices:

• It's important to create space for people of color to tell their own stories.
• These stories should be diverse, nuanced, and authentic.
• They should challenge stereotypes and celebrate the richness of human experience.

The struggle for representation is a struggle for visibility, for recognition, and for the right to be seen as fully human.

7. The Intertwined Nature of Race, Sex, and Power

Powerlessness is a particularly heavy weight to fling off.

Intersectionality of oppression. Race, sex, and power are intertwined and cannot be understood in isolation. The experiences of women of color are shaped by the intersection of these different forms of oppression, and they often face unique challenges and forms of discrimination.

The fetishization of Asian women:

• Asian women are often objectified and hypersexualized in media and popular culture.
• This fetishization can lead to violence and exploitation.
• It can also reinforce harmful stereotypes about Asian women as submissive and docile.

The emasculation of Asian men:

• Asian men are often portrayed as asexual or lacking in masculinity.
• This emasculation can lead to feelings of inadequacy and invisibility.
• It can also reinforce harmful stereotypes about Asian men as weak or unassertive.

The struggle for equality requires a recognition of the complex ways in which race, sex, and power intersect, and it demands a commitment to challenging all forms of oppression.

8. Finding Home: A Journey of Belonging and Displacement

We have inherited the knowledge that community means to remain. When we cannot return to our homes – or are waiting for them to be taken from us again – we must get the hang of how to recreate it elsewhere.

The search for belonging. For immigrants and their children, the concept of "home" can be complex and multifaceted. They may feel a sense of displacement, caught between their heritage and their adopted country, and they may struggle to find a place where they truly belong.

Recreating home:

• Immigrant communities often recreate aspects of their culture in their new homes.
• This can include food, language, music, and traditions.
• These acts of cultural preservation can be a source of comfort and connection.

The fluidity of identity:

• The concept of "home" is not fixed or static.
• It can evolve and change over time.
• It can be found in different places and in different communities.

The journey of finding home is a personal and ongoing one, and it's important to recognize the diversity of experiences and the many ways in which people create a sense of belonging.

9. The Power of Storytelling: Reclaiming Narratives

Storytelling is the most powerful way to promote our understanding of the world in which we live and the vessel to tell these stories is our media.

The importance of diverse narratives. Storytelling has the power to shape our understanding of the world and our place in it. When stories are told from a limited perspective, they can reinforce harmful stereotypes and perpetuate injustice.

Reclaiming narratives:

• People of color need to be empowered to tell their own stories.
• These stories should be authentic, nuanced, and complex.
• They should challenge dominant narratives and offer new perspectives.

The power of representation:

• When people see themselves reflected in the stories that are being told, they feel seen and valued.
• This can lead to a greater sense of belonging and empowerment.
• It can also help to break down stereotypes and promote understanding.

By reclaiming our narratives, we can create a more just and equitable world where everyone's stories are heard and valued.

10. The Unseen Scars of Racism and the Need for Empathy

Understand this – we do not carry our fathers’ names without bearing with them their suffering.

The lasting impact of racism. Racism leaves deep and lasting scars on individuals and communities. These scars are not always visible, but they can have a profound impact on people's lives, affecting their mental health, their sense of self, and their opportunities.

The importance of empathy:

• It's important to listen to and believe the stories of people who have experienced racism.
• It's important to recognize the pain and suffering that racism causes.
• It's important to challenge our own biases and prejudices.

The need for action:

• Empathy is not enough; we must also take action to dismantle systems of oppression.
• This includes challenging racism in all its forms, both individual and systemic.
• It also includes creating a more just and equitable world for all.

By acknowledging the unseen scars of racism and cultivating empathy, we can begin to heal the wounds of the past and build a better future for all.

Last updated: January 24, 2025

Report Issue