Plot Summary

Childhood Lessons in Love

Libby learns love from movies

Libby Buxbaum's childhood was steeped in romantic comedies, thanks to her mother, who taught her to believe in happily ever afters. Her mother's advice was to avoid charming bad boys and seek out dependable nice guys, shaping Libby's romantic ideals. After her mother's passing, these lessons became her guiding light, as she clung to the hope of finding a love story worthy of the movies they cherished together.

Neighborhood Rivalry and Romance

Libby and Wes: childhood adversaries

Libby's life is marked by a playful rivalry with her neighbor, Wes Bennett. Their daily bickering over a parking spot masks an undeniable chemistry. Despite their constant teasing, Libby remains focused on finding her perfect romance, navigating high school life while holding onto her mother's romantic ideals.

Unexpected Encounters and Old Crushes

Michael Young returns, reigniting hope

Libby's world is shaken when her childhood crush, Michael Young, returns to town. His reappearance stirs old feelings, and Libby is determined to make him see her as more than just the girl next door. However, high school dynamics and her rival, Laney Morgan, complicate her quest for a cinematic love story.

Party Mishaps and New Alliances

Libby's party disaster with Wes

At a party with Wes, Libby hopes to reconnect with Michael, but a vomit incident ruins her chances. Despite the embarrassment, Wes helps her, revealing a caring side. This unexpected alliance leads to a pact to help Libby win over Michael, using a fake relationship to spark his interest.

Fashion Advice and Friendship

Wes helps Libby's transformation

Wes takes Libby shopping to update her wardrobe and shed her "Little Liz" image. Despite initial resistance, Libby enjoys Wes's company and his fashion sense. Their growing friendship challenges her perceptions, while she struggles with guilt over keeping her plans from her best friend, Jocelyn.

Basketball Games and Mixed Signals

Libby's mixed feelings at the game

Libby joins Wes and friends at a basketball game, trying to impress Michael but overshadowed by Laney. A bet with Wes helps her engage, but a basketball accident leads to a hospital visit with Wes, bringing them closer and complicating her feelings for both Wes and Michael.

Hospital Visits and Heartfelt Conversations

Libby and Wes bond over mishaps

After the basketball incident, Wes shows genuine concern for Libby, leading to a late-night phone conversation where they share personal stories. Libby begins to question her feelings, realizing her relationship with Wes is more complex than she thought, and must decide if pursuing Michael is worth risking her friendship with Wes.

Emotional Turmoil and Unexpected Revelations

Libby grapples with conflicting emotions

A heated argument with Wes at the cemetery leaves Libby questioning her feelings. Her emotional turmoil is compounded by a confrontation with her stepmother, Helena, who is trying to connect with her. As Libby navigates these emotions, she realizes her pursuit of Michael might not be what she truly wants.

Prom Night: Unforeseen Choices

Libby faces unexpected promposal

On prom night, Michael's grand promposal catches Libby off guard. Despite initial excitement, she realizes her feelings for Michael have changed. Strained relations with Jocelyn and thoughts of Wes complicate the night, leaving Libby to question her choices and what she truly desires.

Confrontations and Realizations

Libby confronts her true desires

After a disastrous prom night, Libby reflects on her decisions. A chance encounter with Wes leads to a heated exchange where both reveal their true feelings. Libby admits her pursuit of Michael was misguided, realizing her heart has always been with Wes, forcing her to reevaluate her priorities.

Reconciliation and New Beginnings

Libby and Wes find common ground

Following their confrontation, Libby and Wes reconcile. Libby apologizes and admits her feelings for Wes, who reveals he has always cared for her. This mutual confession paves the way for a new beginning, marked by understanding and appreciation, setting the stage for a promising relationship.

Love Confessions and Future Plans

Libby and Wes plan their future

With their relationship solidified, Libby and Wes discuss future plans, supporting each other's college pursuits. Libby finds comfort in having Wes by her side, marking the end of her quest for a cinematic love story and the start of a real, meaningful relationship, realizing her story with Wes is better than any movie.

Characters

Libby Buxbaum

Romantic dreamer finds true love

Libby is a high school senior who initially seeks a cinematic love story with her childhood crush, Michael. Her journey leads her to realize her true feelings lie with Wes, her childhood nemesis. Libby evolves as she reconciles her romantic ideals with reality, ultimately finding a genuine connection with Wes.

Wes Bennett

Charming neighbor with hidden depths

Wes is Libby's childhood rival who harbors deeper feelings for her. Known for his playful antics, Wes is revealed to be caring and supportive, challenging Libby's perceptions. His relationship with Libby evolves from playful antagonism to genuine affection, culminating in a heartfelt confession of love.

Michael Young

Charming crush with unclear intentions

Michael is Libby's childhood crush whose return reignites her hopes for romance. His intentions remain ambiguous, serving as a catalyst for Libby's realization that her true feelings lie with Wes.

Jocelyn

Loyal friend with a practical outlook

Jocelyn is Libby's best friend, providing a reality check throughout the story. Her relationship with Libby is strained by secrecy, but they reconcile, highlighting the importance of honesty and communication in friendships.

Laney Morgan

Perfect rival with a hidden agenda

Laney is Libby's high school rival, known for her beauty and charm. She appears to have everything Libby wants, including Michael's attention, representing the obstacles Libby must overcome to achieve her romantic dreams.

Helena

Supportive stepmother seeking connection

Helena is Libby's stepmother who tries to connect with her despite resistance. She represents the challenges of blending families and the importance of understanding and support in overcoming grief and loss.

Plot Devices

Fake Relationship

Strategic deception to win love

The fake relationship between Libby and Wes is central, designed to make Michael see Libby as a romantic option. This arrangement allows Libby to explore her feelings for both Michael and Wes, creating tension and humor as they navigate their faux romance.

Love Triangle

Complicated relationships drive the plot

The love triangle between Libby, Wes, and Michael creates tension and drives Libby's character development. This dynamic forces Libby to confront her true feelings and make difficult choices about her relationships.

Romantic Comedy Tropes

Guiding Libby's quest for love

Libby's life is influenced by romantic comedy tropes, shaping her expectations and actions. These elements add humor and relatability, highlighting the gap between Libby's ideals and reality, as she reconciles her fantasies with real-life relationships.

Analysis

Modern analysis of love and reality

"Better than the Movies" explores the tension between romantic ideals and reality, using familiar romantic comedy tropes to highlight this gap. Libby's journey reflects the universal struggle of reconciling fantasy with real-life relationships, emphasizing the importance of genuine connections over idealized love stories. The book underscores the value of friendship, honesty, and self-discovery, as Libby learns that true love often defies cinematic expectations, leading to a more meaningful and fulfilling relationship. Through humor and relatable characters, Lynn Painter delivers a heartfelt narrative about growing up and finding love in unexpected places.

Last updated:

Report Issue