Key Takeaways
1. Stewardship: Choosing service over self-interest
Stewardship is the choice for service.
Service-oriented mindset. Stewardship represents a fundamental shift in organizational governance, focusing on service rather than self-interest. It involves holding power with grace, distributing ownership and responsibility widely, and being deeply accountable for outcomes without resorting to control or compliance.
Key principles of stewardship:
- Balancing power between all stakeholders
- Committing to the larger community
- Allowing each person to define purpose and decide on organizational culture
- Equitably distributing rewards
Stewardship challenges traditional notions of leadership by emphasizing partnership, empowerment, and service. This approach creates a strong sense of ownership and responsibility at every level of the organization, fostering a more engaged and committed workforce.
2. Shift from leadership to partnership and empowerment
Leadership has often claimed to be in service of those they lead, but the leader's "service" took the form of giving direction and protection. Stewardship serves through the form of giving a basic structure and supporting self-direction.
Redefining power dynamics. Stewardship advocates for a shift from traditional leadership models to partnership and empowerment. This transition involves moving away from hierarchical, control-based systems to more collaborative, trust-based relationships.
Key aspects of this shift include:
- Treating employees as partners rather than subordinates
- Giving people at all levels more choice and control over their work
- Fostering a sense of ownership and responsibility throughout the organization
- Encouraging self-direction and initiative
By embracing this approach, organizations can tap into the full potential of their workforce, leading to increased innovation, adaptability, and overall performance.
3. Rethinking organizational structures and practices
Management becomes a set of tasks and activities, not a full-time job title. Everybody manages, although some have a wider view and a longer time perspective.
Flattening hierarchies. Stewardship calls for a fundamental restructuring of organizational practices and structures. This involves breaking down traditional hierarchies and integrating management functions with core work processes.
Key changes include:
- Reducing the number of management layers
- Organizing around customers or products rather than functions
- Empowering teams to make decisions and manage their own work
- Redefining the role of managers as supporters and facilitators
These structural changes help create a more agile and responsive organization, better equipped to meet customer needs and adapt to changing market conditions.
4. Redesigning financial practices for accountability
When we try to initiate reform by measuring each of the steps along the way, we are in effect trying to control the means of performance instead of the results.
Transparency and trust. Stewardship requires a reimagining of financial practices to promote accountability and trust. This involves moving away from top-down control mechanisms to more collaborative and transparent approaches.
Key financial practices under stewardship:
- Full disclosure of financial information to all employees
- Involving core workers in budgeting and financial decision-making
- Focusing on measuring outcomes rather than controlling processes
- Decentralizing spending authority and financial responsibility
By adopting these practices, organizations can foster a culture of financial stewardship at all levels, leading to more responsible and effective use of resources.
5. Transforming human resources to end paternalism
Human resources practices do not impact the culture of an institution; they are the culture.
Empowering employees. Stewardship calls for a radical transformation of human resources practices, moving away from paternalistic approaches to those that empower and support employees.
Key changes in HR practices:
- Rethinking performance appraisals and compensation systems
- Shifting responsibility for career development to employees
- Redesigning training and development programs to support self-direction
- Focusing on building capabilities rather than controlling behavior
These changes help create a more dynamic and engaged workforce, where employees take greater responsibility for their own development and contribution to the organization.
6. Overcoming cynicism and fostering commitment
Stewardship is an exercise of faith, responsibility, and commitment.
Cultivating belief. Implementing stewardship often faces resistance from cynics, victims, and bystanders. Overcoming this resistance requires a thoughtful approach that acknowledges doubts while inviting commitment.
Strategies for fostering commitment:
- Acknowledging the truth in cynical perspectives
- Framing stewardship as a choice rather than an inevitability
- Inviting others to make the same choice for faith and commitment
- Providing exemptions and pilot programs to demonstrate feasibility
By addressing resistance head-on and inviting active participation, organizations can build the momentum needed for lasting change.
7. Extending stewardship to the common good
Every business organization also is already in this conversation to some extent. The domain is usually called social responsibility.
Broader impact. Stewardship extends beyond individual organizations to address broader societal and environmental concerns. This involves recognizing the interdependence of business, society, and the environment.
Ways organizations can practice stewardship for the common good:
- Developing clear statements of values and commitments to the wider community
- Supporting employee volunteer efforts and board participation in nonprofits
- Establishing foundations to distribute earnings to community causes
- Engaging in social entrepreneurship initiatives
By embracing this broader view of stewardship, organizations can contribute to solving societal problems while also enhancing their own long-term sustainability and social license to operate.
Last updated:
FAQ
1. What is Stewardship: Choosing Service over Self-Interest by Peter Block about?
- Core theme of stewardship: The book explores stewardship as an alternative to traditional leadership, focusing on service, partnership, and empowerment rather than control and self-interest.
- Organizational transformation: It provides a framework for redesigning management, staff roles, and systems to foster accountability, choice, and capability at all levels.
- Societal impact: Block connects stewardship to serving the common good, urging institutions to better serve communities, the environment, and society at large.
2. Why should I read Stewardship: Choosing Service over Self-Interest by Peter Block?
- Timeless and radical insights: The book remains highly relevant, challenging conventional leadership and organizational practices with a radical, values-based approach.
- Practical and spiritual guidance: It offers both actionable strategies and a spiritual anchor for creating organizations that serve the common good.
- Influential and transformative: The book has inspired leaders worldwide to rethink power, accountability, and organizational purpose, making it essential for those seeking meaningful change.
3. What are the key takeaways from Stewardship: Choosing Service over Self-Interest by Peter Block?
- Service over self-interest: Stewardship prioritizes serving others and the organization’s mission above personal or positional power.
- Distributed power and accountability: The book advocates for pushing decision-making and responsibility to those closest to the work and customers.
- Redefining staff and management roles: Staff functions should act as service providers, and supervisors should become coaches and partners rather than controllers.
- Broader purpose: Stewardship extends beyond organizations, calling for institutions to serve the common good and balance economic, social, and environmental responsibilities.
4. What are the best quotes from Stewardship: Choosing Service over Self-Interest by Peter Block and what do they mean?
- “Stewardship is the choice to preside over the orderly distribution of power.” This highlights the core idea of shifting from control to empowerment.
- “Service over self-interest.” Block’s mantra for leaders, emphasizing the need to put the organization and others before personal gain.
- “Partnership balances power between people.” This quote underlines the importance of mutual accountability and shared governance.
- “Without changing the fundamental beliefs about power distribution and accountability, improvements remain limited and temporary.” Block warns that surface-level changes are insufficient without a true shift in governance philosophy.
5. What are the key principles of stewardship according to Peter Block in Stewardship: Choosing Service over Self-Interest?
- Service over self-interest: Leaders and organizations should prioritize serving others and the mission.
- Distributing ownership and responsibility: Decision-making and accountability should be pushed down to those closest to the work.
- Building capability and offering choice: Staff functions must act as authentic service units, allowing line units to choose services and fostering partnership.
- Mutual accountability: All parties are responsible for outcomes, not just those at the top.
6. How does Peter Block define the difference between leadership and stewardship in Stewardship: Choosing Service over Self-Interest?
- Leadership centralizes power: Traditional leadership is about control, defining purpose, and maintaining dependency.
- Stewardship distributes power: Stewardship emphasizes empowerment, partnership, and accountability without control.
- Service over control: Stewardship requires leaders to choose service and shared responsibility over caretaking and dominance.
7. What does Peter Block mean by choosing partnership over patriarchy in organizations in Stewardship: Choosing Service over Self-Interest?
- Patriarchy defined: Patriarchy centralizes power and expects compliance and dependency from those below.
- Partnership as alternative: Partnership balances power, gives more choice and responsibility to those closest to the work, and fosters mutual accountability.
- Four requirements of partnership: These are exchange of purpose, the right to say no, joint accountability, and absolute honesty.
8. What is the “stewardship contract” in Peter Block’s Stewardship: Choosing Service over Self-Interest and why is it important?
- Defines mutual expectations: The contract clarifies the mission, values, principles, and commitments of all parties involved in organizational change.
- Foundation for accountability: It sets the ground rules for empowerment, partnership, and service, ensuring everyone understands their roles.
- Enables negotiation and exceptions: Units can negotiate control and responsibility, requesting exceptions to standard policies to foster local autonomy.
- Focuses attention: The contract helps focus on difficult issues and priorities, setting boundaries for partnership.
9. How does Peter Block recommend redesigning management and staff practices to support stewardship in Stewardship: Choosing Service over Self-Interest?
- Full disclosure and transparency: Sharing complete information with all employees is foundational to breaking the caretaking contract.
- Empowering core workers: Core work teams should own customer relationships, work redesign, quality control, and reporting results.
- Changing supervisor roles: Supervisors become coaches, bankers, brokers, and conveners, supporting teams rather than directing them.
- Redefining staff functions: Staff groups should serve core work teams as authentic service providers, not as enforcers of top management’s control.
10. What changes to financial and human resource practices does Peter Block recommend in Stewardship: Choosing Service over Self-Interest?
- Financial stewardship: Promote full disclosure, economic literacy, and decentralize budgeting and spending authority.
- HR transformation: End paternalistic policies, decentralize HR practices, and restructure HR around customer-oriented teams.
- Performance appraisal and compensation: Replace top-down appraisals with peer and self-directed feedback, and redesign compensation to reward team and organizational outcomes equitably.
11. How does Stewardship: Choosing Service over Self-Interest address the emotional and practical challenges of shifting from dependency to empowerment?
- Acknowledging emotional wants: The book recognizes desires for safety, self-esteem, and freedom that fuel dependency and dominance.
- Saying no to caretaking: It encourages rejecting unfulfillable expectations of protection and control, fostering autonomy.
- Renegotiating social contracts: The shift involves moving from parenting contracts to partnership agreements, accepting ambivalence, and embracing the risks of empowerment.
- Addressing resistance: Block explains sources of resistance and offers strategies to acknowledge doubts while inviting personal choice and responsibility.
12. How does Stewardship: Choosing Service over Self-Interest by Peter Block connect stewardship to serving the common good beyond organizations?
- Extends stewardship principles: The book applies stewardship to broader societal issues like environmental care, social services, education, and health care.
- Critiques profit focus: Block challenges the dominant business perspective of profit maximization, urging institutions to serve communities and the environment responsibly.
- Calls for a new narrative: He advocates for a fundamental conversation about institutional purpose, balancing freedom, service, and security for all.
- Broader impact: Stewardship is presented as a way to create institutions that prioritize the common good over narrow self-interest.
Stewardship receives mixed reviews, with ratings ranging from 2 to 5 stars. Positive reviews praise its thought-provoking ideas on empowerment, partnership, and service-oriented leadership. Critics find it idealistic and impractical, questioning its applicability to all employees. Some readers appreciate Block's challenge to traditional management structures, while others find the writing style unfocused. The book's concepts on democratizing business governance and fostering employee ownership resonate with many, but its execution and clarity are debated.
Contenido de libros similares...
Contenido sobre el autor...