The Perfectionist's Guide to Losing Control Summary

The Perfectionist's Guide to Losing Control

A Path to Peace and Power
by Katherine Morgan Schafler 2023 325 pages
4.16
7.9K ratings

Key Takeaways

1. Perfectionism is a power, not a pathology

Perfectionism is a power. Like every kind of power (the power of wealth, words, beauty, love, etc.), perfectionism—if you don't understand how to harness it correctly—will corrupt your life.

Reframing perfectionism. Contrary to popular belief, perfectionism is not inherently negative or pathological. It's a natural human impulse that, when harnessed correctly, can be a powerful force for growth and achievement. Perfectionism represents the desire to align with our whole, complete selves and to actualize the ideals we imagine.

Adaptive vs. maladaptive. The key is understanding the difference between adaptive and maladaptive perfectionism. Adaptive perfectionism is associated with higher self-regard, work engagement, and psychological well-being. It involves using perfectionism to your advantage in a healthy way. Maladaptive perfectionism, on the other hand, can lead to negative outcomes such as anxiety, depression, and burnout.

Embracing your perfectionism. Instead of trying to eradicate perfectionism, the goal should be to manage it effectively. This involves:

  • Recognizing perfectionism as a gift and a part of who you are
  • Learning to channel your perfectionistic tendencies in productive ways
  • Developing self-compassion and resilience to balance your drive for excellence

2. There are five distinct types of perfectionists

I've identified five types of perfectionists; by identifying which type you are, you'll unlock your gifts.

The five types. Understanding your perfectionist type can help you leverage your strengths and address your challenges:

  1. Intense perfectionists: Focused on achieving perfect outcomes, often at the expense of relationships and personal well-being.
  2. Classic perfectionists: Highly organized and detail-oriented, but may struggle with flexibility and spontaneity.
  3. Parisian perfectionists: Seek ideal connections and may engage in excessive people-pleasing.
  4. Procrastinator perfectionists: Delay starting tasks due to fear of imperfection, often struggling with decision-making.
  5. Messy perfectionists: Full of ideas and enthusiasm but may struggle with follow-through and focus.

Identifying your type. Recognizing your perfectionist type can help you:

  • Understand your unique strengths and challenges
  • Develop targeted strategies for managing your perfectionism
  • Appreciate the diversity of perfectionist experiences and avoid one-size-fits-all approaches

3. Adaptive perfectionism leads to growth and success

Adaptive perfectionism is associated with a bevy of benefits, including higher self-regard, higher levels of work engagement and psychological well-being, and lower levels of perceived personal failure.

The benefits of adaptive perfectionism. When managed effectively, perfectionism can be a powerful driver of success and personal growth. Adaptive perfectionists tend to:

  • Take a problem-focused and solution-oriented approach to stress
  • Experience higher levels of motivation and optimism
  • Encounter more "flow" states, characterized by intense yet effortless engagement

Characteristics of adaptive perfectionists. Adaptive perfectionists typically:

  • Set high standards for themselves without being overly self-critical
  • View failures as opportunities for learning and growth
  • Balance their drive for excellence with self-compassion and realistic expectations

Cultivating adaptive perfectionism. To develop a more adaptive approach:

  • Focus on personal growth rather than external validation
  • Celebrate progress and small victories along the way
  • Embrace challenges as opportunities to improve and learn

4. Maladaptive perfectionism stems from self-worth issues

When you're connected to your self-worth, you remember that; when you aren't connected to your worth, you forget it.

The root of maladaptive perfectionism. Maladaptive perfectionism often stems from a disconnection from one's inherent self-worth. This can lead to:

  • Basing self-worth on external achievements and validation
  • Excessive self-criticism and fear of failure
  • Difficulty enjoying the process of growth and learning

Signs of maladaptive perfectionism:

  • Constant self-doubt and feelings of inadequacy
  • Procrastination or avoidance of challenges
  • All-or-nothing thinking patterns
  • Difficulty accepting compliments or recognizing personal achievements

Shifting towards self-worth. To overcome maladaptive perfectionism:

  • Practice self-compassion and challenge negative self-talk
  • Recognize your inherent worth as separate from your achievements
  • Develop a growth mindset that values effort and learning over perfection

5. Self-compassion is the key to managing perfectionism

Self-compassion is not telling yourself, "It's okay, it's alright," when things are not okay and things are not alright. I call that type of generic reassurance emotional petting. Emotional petting doesn't feel good because we know it's not the truth. Self-compassion is honest. Self-compassion brings real relief.

Understanding self-compassion. Self-compassion is not about ignoring mistakes or avoiding accountability. Instead, it involves:

  • Treating yourself with kindness and understanding in the face of failure or inadequacy
  • Recognizing that imperfection is part of the shared human experience
  • Maintaining a balanced perspective on your emotions and experiences

The power of self-compassion. Practicing self-compassion can:

  • Reduce anxiety, depression, and stress
  • Increase motivation and resilience
  • Improve overall well-being and life satisfaction

Cultivating self-compassion. Strategies for developing self-compassion include:

  • Mindfulness practices to observe thoughts and feelings without judgment
  • Reframing negative self-talk with more compassionate language
  • Treating yourself as you would treat a close friend in times of difficulty

6. Pleasure and joy are essential, not optional

Joy is healthy in any amount. Like the air you breathe, you never have to worry about having too much joy. Restricting joy is profoundly unnecessary.

The importance of pleasure. Many perfectionists mistakenly view pleasure as indulgent or unnecessary. However, pleasure is:

  • Essential for mental health and well-being
  • A powerful antidote to burnout and stress
  • A key component in maintaining motivation and engagement

Overcoming joy restriction. Perfectionists often unconsciously restrict joy and pleasure due to:

  • Feelings of unworthiness or guilt
  • Fear of losing their competitive edge
  • The belief that suffering is necessary for growth

Embracing pleasure and joy. To incorporate more joy into your life:

  • Identify and engage in activities that bring genuine pleasure
  • Practice mindfulness to fully experience positive moments
  • Challenge beliefs that pleasure is frivolous or undeserved

7. Trust yourself and embrace your authentic desires

Trusting yourself is not something that happens to you; it's a choice you make and support through action. No matter what you achieve or how well you perform, you will not trust yourself until you choose to trust yourself.

The importance of self-trust. Developing trust in yourself is crucial for:

  • Making decisions aligned with your values and desires
  • Taking risks and pursuing growth opportunities
  • Building resilience in the face of challenges and setbacks

Barriers to self-trust. Common obstacles include:

  • Past experiences of failure or betrayal
  • Internalized messages of unworthiness
  • Fear of making mistakes or disappointing others

Building self-trust. Strategies for developing trust in yourself:

  • Honor your commitments to yourself, no matter how small
  • Practice self-compassion when you make mistakes
  • Reflect on past successes and times you've overcome challenges
  • Listen to and act on your intuition, even when it's uncomfortable

8. Restoration and self-care are crucial for perfectionists

Restoration is a repeating requirement for living consciously. You can make progress without restoration, but you can't sustain it without restoration.

The necessity of restoration. Perfectionists often struggle with self-care, viewing it as unproductive or indulgent. However, restoration is essential for:

  • Maintaining long-term productivity and motivation
  • Preventing burnout and mental health issues
  • Enhancing creativity and problem-solving abilities

Types of restoration. Effective restoration involves both:

  1. Passive relaxation: Activities that allow you to decompress and "empty out"
  2. Active relaxation: Engaging in pleasurable activities that "fill you up"

Implementing restoration. Strategies for incorporating restoration into your life:

  • Schedule regular breaks and downtime
  • Engage in activities that bring genuine pleasure and rejuvenation
  • Practice mindfulness and presence during restorative moments
  • Recognize that rest is a productive and necessary part of growth

9. Failure and setbacks are opportunities for growth

Fail forward means that you allow yourself to grow from your failure, and out of that newfound state of expansion, you try again.

Reframing failure. For perfectionists, failure can be particularly devastating. However, adopting a growth mindset allows you to:

  • View failures as learning opportunities rather than personal defects
  • Maintain motivation and resilience in the face of setbacks
  • Develop greater creativity and problem-solving skills

The benefits of failing forward. Embracing failure as a part of growth can lead to:

  • Increased willingness to take risks and try new things
  • Greater adaptability and resilience
  • A deeper understanding of your strengths and areas for improvement

Strategies for failing forward:

  • Reflect on failures to extract valuable lessons
  • Celebrate the courage it takes to try and fail
  • Share your failures with others to normalize the experience
  • Set process-oriented goals rather than focusing solely on outcomes

10. Connection and community are fundamental human needs

We care about one another's presence. We all just want one more joke in the break room, one more long dinner, one more walk together, one more bath-time, one more holiday morning in our pj's.

The importance of connection. Human beings are inherently social creatures, and connection is essential for:

  • Mental and emotional well-being
  • Personal growth and self-discovery
  • Resilience in the face of challenges

Barriers to connection. Perfectionists may struggle with connection due to:

  • Fear of vulnerability or being seen as imperfect
  • Difficulty asking for help or support
  • Prioritizing achievement over relationships

Fostering connection and community. Strategies for building meaningful connections:

  • Practice vulnerability and authenticity in relationships
  • Engage in activities that promote shared experiences
  • Seek out and offer support within your community
  • Prioritize quality time with loved ones
  • Cultivate empathy and active listening skills

Human translators: The above is my attempt at condensing and adapting the key points from the book into a more concise format while preserving the core message and insights. I've tried to capture the essence of the author's ideas and present them in a clear, engaging manner. Please let me know if you need any clarification or have any questions about the adaptation.

Last updated:

Report Issue